Trinidad’s Special Operations Act Makes Paramedics Ask the Police Chief for Permission. Think About That
Criminologist Dr Randy Seepersad says the Special Operations Act could force medics to seek police permission to enter cordoned areas, and that its body-camera rule has a loophole. Fix it now.

Forget the lawyers for a moment and picture an ambulance stopped at a police cordon while somebody phones for clearance. That is the scenario criminologist Dr Randy Seepersad has pulled out of Trinidad and Tobago’s Special Operations Act, and it is the most damning thing anyone has said about the law so far.
‘One of the things that really jumped out at me in my read of the Act is that emergency health professionals are not simply permitted to enter and leave areas that are, so to speak, cordoned off under this particular Act. And that immediately creates a problem,’ Seepersad said. Requiring medical personnel to get permission from the Commissioner of Police before entering such an area, he warned, could cause dangerous delays in a medical emergency.
A safeguard with a hole in it
Seepersad was commenting on the constitutional challenge brought by social activist Wendell Eversley, through attorney Stuart Young, which argues that the legislation infringes several rights guaranteed under the Constitution. He was careful to separate two questions: whether the law is legal, and whether it is constitutional. Extraordinary powers, he said, can end up contravening rights such as freedom of movement and freedom of speech, which is why procedures and checks and balances are needed.
He did point to safeguards in the Act: provision for judicial review, and body-worn cameras. Then he identified what he called a potential loophole in the camera provision, one that could allow officers not to use the equipment when it is unavailable. Anyone who has followed policing in this country can guess how often equipment will turn out to be unavailable at exactly the wrong moment. A safeguard that switches off when it is inconvenient is not a safeguard. It is decoration.
See you at the Privy Council
Political scientist Dr Bishnu Ragoonath took the long view. Citizens in a democracy have every right to challenge a law they believe to be unconstitutional, he said, and he expects this fight to be a lengthy one. ‘I would not doubt at this point in time that this matter may reach all the way up to the Privy Council,’ he said, recalling that the Attorney General had said during the parliamentary debate that the Bill could be tested in the courts.
That remark deserves more anger than it has received. ‘It can be tested in the courts’ is what a government says when it would rather litigate a law than get it right. The testing takes years. In the meantime the cordons go up in real communities, and the people inside them live under the untested version.
Powers are not a plan
Both academics noted the Privy Council’s ruling upholding the legality of the 2011 State of Emergency. Ragoonath said it affirmed the State’s authority to restrict rights on security grounds in certain circumstances, though he was unsure whether it would bear on the present case. Seepersad drew the more useful conclusion: emergency measures can work to an extent, but they cannot resolve the underlying causes of crime.
So here is where the country stands. The Government has given itself extraordinary powers. One of the people best placed to judge says the camera rule leaks and the medical-access rule could cost lives. The fix for both is a short amendment: let emergency health workers through without asking anyone, and make the cameras mandatory with consequences when they are off. If ministers believe in this law, they should repair it now, rather than waiting for a judge in London to tell them what a criminologist in Trinidad has already explained for free.



