No Bail for Guyana’s Opposition Leader: The Judge Was Careful. The Country Still Has a Problem
Guyana's High Court upheld a magistrate's refusal of bail for Opposition Leader Azruddin Mohamed, but said he may reapply as the case develops.

Azruddin Mohamed, Guyana’s Leader of the Opposition, will stay in a prison cell. The High Court on Wednesday threw out his challenge to a magistrate’s refusal of bail, which means the man chosen to lead the parliamentary opposition remains on remand, unconvicted, while the National Assembly meets without him.
What the court decided
Justice Priscilla Chandra-Hanif dismissed Mohamed’s application for judicial review, finding he had failed to establish the grounds he relied on and that Sparendaam Magistrate Abigail Gibbs had justifiably refused bail. Mohamed is on remand on a cybercrime charge that, according to earlier reporting, relates to his access to police surveillance footage of a shooting incident.
The ruling was not a rubber stamp, and it deserves to be read fairly. The judge said a court “must not” treat the mere existence of an accusation as proof of a tendency to offend. But she found the prosecution’s case went beyond the bare fact of other pending charges. It relied, she said, on a claimed connection between the conduct alleged in the different charges, including allegations about obstruction of justice and interference with witnesses. A magistrate is entitled to weigh whether an accused might interfere with a witness or influence evidence, and the law does not require a court to wait for another offence to happen before recognising a properly evidenced risk.
She also left the door open. Mohamed, she said, “remains entitled at all times to renew his application for bail before the magistrate” as the case develops, particularly once the prosecution discloses its evidence or circumstances change.
Law is one thing. Legitimacy is another
On the law, this looks like an orthodox decision. Courts refuse bail to people accused of tampering with justice every day, and a politician is not entitled to gentler treatment than a fisherman. Those in Mohamed’s camp who are already shouting persecution should read the judgment before they read their talking points.
But those are allegations, and that word has to carry its full weight. Nothing has been proved. And the consequences here are not ordinary. On the same day, the Speaker refused to let Mohamed join the sitting remotely from Lusignan Prison. A candidate elected on his party’s ticket is before the courts on a terrorism charge. Somebody posted a death threat against the Speaker on Parliament’s own live stream.
What should happen now
A democracy can survive an opposition leader facing charges. It struggles when he is held for a long stretch before trial while the governing side runs the House unopposed by its chief critic, because half the country will conclude the outcome was arranged, whatever the evidence says.
The answer is speed and daylight. The prosecution should disclose its evidence quickly, because the judge made disclosure the hinge on which a fresh bail application turns. The magistrate’s court should give the case priority. And the Government should resist every temptation to gloat. If the evidence is strong, a prompt trial will show it. If it is not, each week Mohamed spends on remand becomes harder to defend and easier to exploit.


