Skip to content
Thursday, 19 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

British Virgin Islands

Walwyn Calls the BVI’s Anti-Corruption Rule a ‘Waste of Time’. Mather Answers With Spider-Man, and Wins

Myron Walwyn says the BVI’s post-Commission of Inquiry constituency policy is an ‘utter waste of time’. Stacy Mather says lawmakers are forgetting why it exists. Mather is right.

Walwyn Calls the BVI’s Anti-Corruption Rule a ‘Waste of Time’. Mather Answers With Spider-Man, and Wins
Photo: Colin Riegels / Legis at en.wikipedia / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

It has taken the Virgin Islands remarkably little time to start resenting the rules written to stop its politicians handing out public money as they pleased. Sixth District Representative Myron Walwyn has told the House of Assembly that the constituency policy brought in after the Commission of Inquiry is an ‘utter waste of time’, arguing that its restrictions stop elected members giving meaningful help to struggling constituents and that the need in society far outweighs the resources the policy allows.

At-Large Representative Stacy ‘Budda’ Mather replied in the same sitting, and reached for an unlikely authority. ‘I watched Spiderman a couple weeks ago, and I keep thinking, with great power comes great responsibility,’ he said. ‘I know we went through the COI and sometimes I think in here, we forget why we went through it.’

Why the rule exists

Mather’s film reference will get the laughs, but his second sentence is the one that matters. The territory went through a Commission of Inquiry and a raft of governance reforms for a reason. Those reforms were not designed to make representatives’ lives easy. They were designed to put distance between a politician’s discretion and the public purse.

So when a legislator complains that the constituency policy prevents him from providing meaningful assistance, the honest translation is that it prevents him from providing it personally, on his own judgment, to people who will remember who helped them at the next election. That is not a flaw in the policy. That is the policy working.

Walwyn’s point, taken seriously

None of this means Walwyn is wrong about the need. People in the territory are struggling, and if the money set aside is too small, that is a real grievance. But the answer to inadequate help is a better-funded, properly run social assistance system that treats a hungry family the same whichever district it lives in and whoever it voted for. It is not a return to representatives with cheque books.

Mather put the principle well. Leaders, he argued, should use the resources available to focus on the most vulnerable rather than everyone who turns up with a problem. ‘The man who has five children to feed is not the same as the man that has one,’ he said. ‘So sometimes we as leaders have to make decisions that might not be popular but they might be equitable.’ Equity over popularity is exactly the instinct the reforms were meant to install.

Then the back-slapping began

Mather weakened his own case in the next breath. He scolded opposition members for failing to praise Premier Dr Natalio Wheatley for delivering pension increases to retired public officers, including retroactive payments. ‘The Premier stood up here and promised the pensioners, and he delivered,’ he said. ‘I think political maturity must come to the point where we are able to say, to your colleague on either side, job well done.’

Here is the detail that takes the shine off. Those pensioners had gone approximately 25 years without a general adjustment. Ending a quarter-century of neglect is welcome. It is not a favour, and no opposition is obliged to applaud a government for finally paying people what was long overdue. Maturity runs both ways: a governing side confident in its record does not need to fish for compliments.

Still, on the main question Mather has the better of it. The Virgin Islands accepted outside scrutiny and hard rules because its own system had failed to police itself. Legislators who now find those rules irritating should say which specific restriction they would lift, and what would stop the old habits returning the day after. Until someone answers that, ‘utter waste of time’ is not an argument. It is nostalgia.

0
0

More in British Virgin Islands

View all →

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.