Mottley Wants a Political Boss and New Taxes for CARICOM. First Explain What CARICOM Has Done for Anyone Lately
Barbados PM Mia Mottley says CARICOM needs a political head funded by new import and tourist levies. A UWI lecturer says the bloc must first show people regionalism works.

Mia Mottley has diagnosed what is wrong with the Caribbean Community and prescribed a cure: give it a political head and a tax base. “Without a political head, CARICOM will not go any further,” the Barbadian Prime Minister said on Sunday at a book launch at The University of the West Indies. She is right that the organisation is stuck. Her remedy puts the roof on before the walls.
The proposal
Mottley argued that CARICOM needs a leader who can provide continuity, speak for the region’s interests and make sure decisions taken by member states are actually carried out. To pay for a stronger body she proposed a 0.3 per cent tax on United States imports into the region, a US$1 levy on cruise ship passengers and a US$2 tax on visitors staying longer.
Damion Gordon, a lecturer in government at UWI, is not persuaded. CARICOM, he said, faces a crisis of credibility and legitimacy and struggles to find common ground on sovereignty and foreign policy, but a political head may not be the answer. “People need to see the benefits of regionalism and, over time, that will build support,” he said. “But, if people believe that regionalism doesn’t work, which is certainly a broad view among CARICOM nationals, then that undermines the project in itself.” On the levies: “We can’t be thinking about levying and taxing on all of that.” He would start with easier regional travel, more trade and wider educational and cultural exchange.
She has the problem right
Give Mottley credit for saying aloud what most heads of government only mutter. CARICOM is 53 years old and still runs on communiqués. Leaders meet, agree, fly home and do as they please. There is nobody whose job is to chase them. On the biggest questions now facing the region, from foreign policy to the European Union’s demands over citizenship programmes, member states are answering one by one.
And the solution backwards
But Gordon has the better of the argument. A political head only has authority if governments are prepared to be told what to do, and the entire history of the organisation says they are not. Create the post without that willingness and you get one more official issuing statements that capitals ignore, this time with a bigger title and a salary.
Then the money. Every one of the three proposed levies lands on ordinary people or on the industry that feeds them. A tax on American imports is a tax on groceries in a region that imports much of its food from the United States. Cruise lines play islands off against each other over a dollar a head already. Asking a public that, by Gordon’s account, broadly believes regionalism does not work to pay more for it is asking for a revolt.
The order matters. Ordinary Caribbean people will fund a regional body when it does something they can feel: a flight from Kingston to Port of Spain that does not cost more than one to Miami, a qualification recognised next door, a work permit they do not need. Deliver two of those and the case for a political head makes itself.
Mottley has the standing to push for exactly that. Leading with a new office and new taxes hands every sceptic in the region their argument ready-made.


