Fifteen Seconds: British Report on the Bayesian Says the Crew Never Knew the Yacht’s Weakness. An Antiguan Chef Died Aboard
Britain’s final report on the Bayesian sinking, which killed Antiguan chef Recaldo Thomas and six others, says the crew were unaware of the superyacht’s vulnerability to extreme wind.

Recaldo Thomas told a friend in Antigua he was tired and needed only two more seasons at sea, so he could fix up his late parents’ house. He never got them.
Mr Thomas, an Antiguan citizen, was the chef aboard the superyacht Bayesian when it sank off northern Sicily on August 19, 2024. He was one of seven people killed. Britain’s Marine Accident Investigation Branch has now published its final report, and its central finding is disturbing: the people responsible for the 56-metre vessel were unaware of how vulnerable it was to extreme wind.
What the investigators found
The yacht was anchored outside the port of Porticello in the early hours. Wind rose from 8 knots to about 70 knots within minutes. The forecast had predicted gusts of up to 27. A violent downburst knocked the vessel onto its side in less than 15 seconds.
The report says the yacht had never been ‘assessed at anchor with its sails down’. It found that once the vessel heeled beyond its angle of vanishing stability, assessed at 73 degrees, a knockdown was ‘irrecoverable’. The centreboard, which would have added stability, was raised. And the extreme winds that night ‘were not explicitly forecast’, so the crew had no warning.
Principal inspector Simon Graves summed it up: ‘It was very dynamic, the speed of events overtook the crew and prevented them from taking any other action.’
Two investigations, two stories
That conclusion sits awkwardly beside what has been reported from Italy, where a separate criminal inquiry continues. Three crew members remain under investigation there. Prosecution experts are reported to have pointed to errors by the crew, not to the vessel. The British report’s account differs, possibly, it is suggested, because Italian prosecutors restricted access to some witnesses and evidence.
Nobody has been convicted of anything, and it is not for commentators to decide between the two versions. But the British findings raise a question that reaches well beyond one night in Sicily. If a vessel of this size and price could have a stability weakness that was never assessed in the condition in which it spent most of its nights, at anchor with sails down, what else is nobody checking?
Why this matters in Antigua
Antigua and Barbuda is one of the world’s great yachting centres. Every season, Antiguans sign on as chefs, deckhands, engineers and stewards on vessels owned by some of the richest people alive. Friends described Mr Thomas as kind, well loved and an inspiration to young black children who wanted to get into yachting.
Those young people deserve to know that the boats they join have been properly assessed and that the people in charge have been told what the limits are. That responsibility lies with builders, owners, classification bodies and flag authorities, long before it reaches a crew woken by a storm.
A country that supplies so much of the industry’s workforce, and hosts so many of its vessels, has standing to ask for more. Antigua’s maritime authorities should study this report and say publicly what they will require of yachts that hire Antiguans and berth in Antiguan harbours. Mr Thomas wanted two more seasons. The least the industry owes him is that those who follow him get theirs.



