Skip to content
Thursday, 19 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

Antigua & Barbuda

Move the 1.5°C Goalposts and Small Islands Drown: Antigua Draws Its Red Line at COP31

Some countries at COP31 want the 1.5-degree warming benchmark raised because it has already been breached. Antigua and Barbuda says that is a red line, and it is right.

Move the 1.5°C Goalposts and Small Islands Drown: Antigua Draws Its Red Line at COP31
Illustration: AI-generated image

Having failed to hold global warming to 1.5 degrees, some governments at COP31 now want to solve the problem by changing the number. Antigua and Barbuda has told them no, and it is right. You do not fix a missed target by painting a new one further down the road, least of all when the people standing on that road are islanders with nowhere higher to go.

The red line

Speaking from the summit in Türkiye as talks entered their final stretch, Antigua and Barbuda’s minister Michael Joseph, who is leading the country’s case there, said small island developing states had set firm red lines and that the 1.5-degree benchmark from the 2015 Paris Agreement is one of them. Some countries, he said, argue that because warming has already passed that level, the benchmark should be raised.

“For us as small island developing states, we can’t move the benchmark, because it means that it opens that doorway for even greater overshoot, which we’re already seeing the impacts of,” Joseph said. The islands always knew 1.5 would hurt their economies, ecosystems and livelihoods, he added, but it was a level they could manage with adaptation and financing in place.

Beyond defending the number, the region wants a science-guided process to keep any overshoot as short as possible and bring temperatures back down, more access to adaptation finance, and real emission cuts from the high-emitting countries. Joseph said Antigua and Barbuda’s negotiators had met the European Union, the G77 and China, the United Kingdom, Australia and Türkiye, that a first draft of the main decision was already out, and that a second was expected on Wednesday.

The trick being attempted

Strip away the diplomatic language and here is what the benchmark-movers are proposing. They burned the carbon. They missed the limit they signed. And their remedy is to redefine failure as the new normal, so that 1.7 or 2 degrees becomes the respectable ambition and nobody has to explain why 1.5 was abandoned. It is the logic of a debtor who cannot make the repayment and so asks the bank to forget what the loan was for.

For a continental economy that is an accounting convenience. For Antigua and Barbuda it is coastline, reefs, fresh water and hurricane seasons. Every tenth of a degree conceded on paper is paid for in the Caribbean in sea walls, insurance premiums and rebuilt roofs, by countries that contributed almost nothing to the problem.

Optimism is not a strategy

Where Joseph deserves a harder look is his mood. “I’m hopeful and quite optimistic that this won’t be another international talk shop,” he said, adding that the main disagreements are about how to reach the goals, not the goals themselves. He looks forward to a final text “very lucid and keeping 1.5 alive”.

Caribbean delegations have been hopeful and optimistic at these summits for years. A sentence in a final document reaffirming 1.5 would be welcome, and it would also be worth exactly as much as the emission cuts and adaptation money behind it. The slogan has been kept alive at one conference after another while the thing itself slipped away.

So hold the red line, minister, and good. But come home with more than a reaffirmed paragraph. Tell Antiguans and Barbudans what finance was actually pledged, by whom, and by when, and which big emitters agreed to cut what. A lucid document that changes nothing is still a talk shop. It just has better drafting.

0
0

More in Antigua & Barbuda

View all →

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.