Skip to content
Sunday, 22 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

Jamaica

Starlink Audit: Kevin Blake Says the Records Exist. Then 157 Devices Should Be Easy to Find

The police commissioner insists the Force kept records of 696 donated Starlink units. The audit's real question is who chose the 75 recipients, and why 37 of them never replied.

Starlink Audit: Kevin Blake Says the Records Exist. Then 157 Devices Should Be Easy to Find
Illustration: AI-generated image

The Starlink audit has done something rare in Jamaica: it has made a Commissioner of Police argue with the Auditor General in writing, in front of his own officers. Dr Kevin Blake used the November 19 edition of Force Orders to tell members of the Jamaica Constabulary Force that the criticism of how it handled 696 donated satellite internet devices after Hurricane Melissa was unfair. He may even be partly right. But the fight he has picked is the wrong one, and the people who ought to be answering questions are not wearing uniforms.

What the auditors found

The Hurricane Melissa Relief Initiative Audit, tabled in the House of Representatives last Tuesday, says energy and telecommunications minister Daryl Vaz authorised the JCF in February 2026 to distribute and safeguard the 696 donated Starlink units. According to the auditors, the Force kept no record of the devices it received and offered no evidence that they were booked in as inventory. As a result, the auditors could not verify how many the JCF actually took in.

The report says 683 of the 696 went out to 75 recipients with no documented allocation criteria and no formal transfer arrangements. The auditors then wrote to 70 recipients said to hold 670 devices: 530 with government bodies and 140 with non-government recipients. Only 33 replied, 28 of 57 government recipients and five of 13 outside government. Receipt of 513 devices was independently confirmed. The other 157 remain unconfirmed because 37 recipients simply did not answer.

Blake’s defence, and where it falls short

The commissioner says the Force’s Technology Branch built a temporary inventory system, logged each unit by serial number and tied each one to the identification of the person who collected it. ‘These are not matters of opinion. They are matters supported by records, records which were made available to the audit team,’ he wrote. He argues that a recipient’s silence is not proof that the JCF lost track of anything, and that the Force never chose who got the devices or on what basis. It was, he says, a courier with reach and security, brought in by the ministry.

Take him at his word and the conclusion is damning, just not for the police. If the JCF only carried out instructions, then somebody else decided which 75 recipients deserved emergency connectivity, and decided it without written criteria. That somebody sits in the ministry that asked the Force to do the job. The audit’s sharpest line is not about serial numbers. It is that nobody can show why one community, agency or organisation got a device and another did not.

There is also the plain embarrassment of 37 recipients, most of them inside government, who could not be bothered to reply to the Auditor General about public property handed to them in a national disaster. Blake calls that a limitation of the verification exercise. It is a limitation of the public service, and it is the part of this story that should worry taxpayers most.

Who should answer now

Blake says accountability ‘must be fair, evidence-based and proportionate’, and warns that harsh scrutiny could make officers reluctant to take on emergency work beyond their normal duties. That is a reasonable worry badly aimed. Officers who worked through the hurricane, many of them personally hit by it, deserve credit. A commissioner who fires back at the state’s auditor in an internal bulletin does not strengthen that case; he turns a records question into a turf war.

The fix is simple. If the serial-number logs and ID records exist, publish a summary: device counts by recipient, with dates. Let the ministry publish the criteria it used, or admit it had none. And let the 37 silent recipients be named to Parliament until they answer. Until then, the Force’s records are a claim, the ministry’s choices are a mystery, and 157 devices are still waiting to be found on paper.

0
0
Share this story

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Jamaica

View all →

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.