Skip to content
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

Community

Thirty-Four Dead in One Raid, Two Soldiers Killed in Camp, and a Law to Keep Bukele’s Troops Out of Any Courtroom: Haiti’s War Has No Referee

Haitian police report 34 killed in a raid backed by Salvadoran troops, two Salvadoran soldiers have died in an explosion, and El Salvador’s Congress has moved to shield its forces from international courts.

Thirty-Four Dead in One Raid, Two Soldiers Killed in Camp, and a Law to Keep Bukele’s Troops Out of Any Courtroom: Haiti’s War Has No Referee
Photo: U.S. Navy photo by Chief Mass Communication Specialist James / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

El Salvador’s Congress has passed a law to make sure its soldiers in Haiti can never be handed to an international tribunal. It did so in the same week Haitian police announced 34 people killed in a single operation those soldiers supported. Anyone who thinks those two facts are unrelated has not been paying attention.

The Haitian National Police said Thursday’s offensive targeted an area controlled by gang leader Renel Destina and involved drones, attack helicopters and armoured vehicles, backed by a task force and members of the Salvadoran military. It reported 34 deaths ‘among the criminal gangs’ and gave few other details, including none on casualties among the security forces.

Who counted the 34?

That figure is the police’s own. There is no independent tally, no list of names and no account of how the dead were identified as gang members. In a densely populated district attacked from the air, that is not a detail. It is the whole question.

According to the United Nations, most Salvadoran soldiers in Haiti operate outside the UN-backed Gang Suppression Force and are not covered by its reporting mechanism. The terms of the agreement between Port-au-Prince and San Salvador have never been published. Analysts have raised concerns about the risk to civilians and the lack of transparency over rules of engagement.

Immunity, written in advance

Now add the new law. It gives President Nayib Bukele authority to take whatever measures are needed to ensure deployed personnel are not surrendered to any international tribunal, entity or foreign state for trial. Congress added that this must not prejudice treaties El Salvador has ratified, a caveat whose practical weight remains to be seen.

Governments do not legislate against prosecution for troops they expect to behave impeccably. An army confident in its conduct invites scrutiny. This one has arranged, ahead of time, to avoid it.

The first Salvadoran deaths

On Friday El Salvador’s army said two of its soldiers were killed and two injured while handling explosive material at one of their camps, the first deaths among the roughly 2,500 troops sent since late October. Bukele deployed them after four Salvadoran air force technicians working with the Gang Suppression Force were ambushed near Port-au-Prince on October 18. A gang leader has claimed the four are dead, without evidence; San Salvador insists they are alive and says its forces will leave once they are found.

What began as a rescue has become an offensive, promoted by Bukele on social media a day after he launched his bid for a third term.

Why Haitians cheer, and why that is not enough

None of this means the gangs deserve sympathy. They have strangled Haiti for years, and many Haitians have rallied in support of the troops. Their government reportedly wants the deployment extended. After so much abandonment, relief at any force that fights back is entirely understandable.

But a state is not rebuilt by body counts that nobody can check. Legislative elections, last held in 2016, have slipped again from December to March. Only 962,321 voters, 16.4 per cent of those eligible, had registered by November 19. Haiti is a CARICOM member, and CARICOM has said almost nothing about foreign troops operating there under secret terms with pre-arranged immunity. It should demand the agreement be published and insist on independent monitoring of every operation. Security bought without accountability is only a different kind of lawlessness.

0
0
Share this story

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Community

View all →

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.