Skip to content
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

Politics

Essequibo Dispute: Venezuela Rejects the World Court Again, and Washington’s Wording Hands Caracas the Opening It Wanted

Venezuela’s interim president has again rejected the ICJ’s authority over Essequibo and demanded talks, a day after a US statement left room for a boundary set ‘with the consent of both parties’.

Essequibo Dispute: Venezuela Rejects the World Court Again, and Washington’s Wording Hands Caracas the Opening It Wanted
Photo: Dan Lundberg / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)

The Essequibo dispute has entered its most dangerous phase in years, not because Venezuela said anything new, but because the United States has started saying something slightly different. A day after Washington restated its position on the border, Venezuela’s interim President Delcy Rodríguez Gómez declared again that her country will not recognise the International Court of Justice or anything it decides.

‘Venezuela reaffirms its historic stance of rejecting the fraudulent 1899 arbitral award, as well as its non-recognition of the International Court of Justice—or any related decision emanating from that body—to settle the territorial dispute over the Guayana Esequiba,’ she said in a statement posted on social media.

What we know so far

Rodríguez is insisting on bilateral talks over the 160,000 square kilometre region, which has been under Guyana’s control for more than a century. She relies on Venezuela’s own reading of the 1966 Geneva Agreement, which she says ‘mandates resolving this dispute through negotiations satisfactory to both parties’. The ICJ has already ruled that it has jurisdiction, and Venezuela has taken part in every stage of the case while objecting to it.

The US State Department’s statement, issued amid reports that then policy chief Jeremy Lewin told Guyana’s Foreign Secretary Robert Persaud in September that he could help broker territorial talks, reads: the 1899 Award ‘should be respected unless or until a new boundary is set by a competent legal body or with the consent of both parties.’

President Irfaan Ali said on Thursday that the American position is clear: ‘They respect our sovereignty. They respect our territorial integrity and we’ve made it very clear that the ICJ ruling is what all of us will have to accept and that is it.’ Guyana’s Foreign Ministry says it has been assured nothing has changed.

Six words Georgetown should not ignore

Read the American sentence again. ‘Or with the consent of both parties’ is the language of negotiation, and negotiation is exactly what Caracas is demanding and Georgetown has spent years refusing. Washington can say its policy has not changed. Venezuela heard an invitation and answered within a day.

Professor Mark Kirton, of the University of the West Indies’ Institute of International Relations, is openly sceptical. He points to US Defence Secretary Peter Hegseth’s remark in Caracas, after a new military cooperation agreement, that ‘Venezuela has gone from our most aggressive regional threat to a compliant security partner’. That, Kirton said, suggests ‘there could very well be an approach towards some form of mediation’ or pressure on Guyana to begin fresh negotiations ‘which would never be in our interest’.

Assurances are not guarantees

Ali’s confidence is understandable in public. In private his government should be assuming the worst. A superpower that has just signed a defence pact with Caracas, and now describes it as a partner, has interests that no longer line up neatly with a small neighbour’s court case. Verbal assurances cost Washington nothing.

Guyana’s strength has always been the law: a binding award, a court with jurisdiction, and a refusal to bargain over what is already its own. The moment it agrees to ‘talks’, the 1899 line becomes an opening bid. CARICOM governments should say so loudly and together, now, while the ruling is still pending. Kirton urged Guyana to keep arguing that the award is ‘full final and perfect’. That is not stubbornness. It is the only position from which a small state wins.

0
0
Share this story

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Politics

View all →

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.