One Logistics Clerk Sank Jamaica’s Hurricane Relief? ODPEM’s Scapegoat Story Insults Everyone Who Donated
ODPEM admits $45 million in donated funds went to the wrong purpose and confirms a MOCA criminal probe, while a departed employee is cast as the villain. The question is who was supervising.
Somebody in government would like Jamaicans to believe that a single logistics employee is the reason hurricane relief rotted in a warehouse. It is a convenient story, and it falls apart the moment you ask who was supposed to be watching him.
The auditor general’s 60-page report on Hurricane Melissa relief, tabled in Parliament on Tuesday, described more than 200 bags of weevil-infested rice in a warehouse run by the Office of Disaster Preparedness and Emergency Management, insects on food despite a $450,000 fumigation exercise, 359 boxes of crackers past their best-before dates, 15 unopened containers that appeared nowhere in the inventory and roughly $780 million in shipments left off the agency’s donation schedules.
The explanation: blame the donors, then blame the staff
At Wednesday’s post-Cabinet briefing, ODPEM Director General Commander Alvin Gayle offered the first line of defence. Some food, he said, arrived already expired or very close to it, and he asked the public for grace given the scale of the event. He insisted no Melissa funds were unaccounted for and said new standard operating procedures now govern how supplies are received, recorded, stored and handed out.
Then came the admission that matters. About $45 million of donated money was used to pay customs charges on relief shipments consigned to third parties. ODPEM accepts that this fell outside the approved purpose of the fund and that the paperwork and financial controls were not kept as they should have been. The money is to be put back once an additional allocation arrives, which the agency hopes will be within two weeks. It would not say where that allocation is coming from.
Gayle also confirmed that the Major Organised Crime and Anti-Corruption Agency is running a criminal investigation, while a separate inquiry considers internal discipline. A senior employee has resigned in the middle of all this, and nobody has been charged with anything.
The political sideshow
Into that gap stepped the suggestion that the departed employee was an Opposition plant. The People’s National Party says it checked its membership records and found no trace of him as a member or an agent. General Secretary Dr Dayton Campbell called the saboteur theory a distraction and put the obvious question: ‘Who authorised these payments? Who supervised this employee?’
He is right, and the point does not depend on which party you vote for. If one mid-level officer could redirect donor funds, leave containers sealed for a year and let food spoil, then the agency had no management worth the name. If he could not, the story is a smear aimed at a man who is not in the room to answer it. Either way the claim damages the people making it.
The Prime Minister owns this one
After Melissa, ODPEM was taken from the Ministry of Local Government and placed under the Office of the Prime Minister, with Gayle seconded from the Jamaica Defence Force to run it. That was sold as a show of seriousness. It also means there is no junior minister left to absorb the blow. The agency’s failures happened on Andrew Holness’s desk, and the PNP’s demand that he give a full account is the minimum the moment requires.
Jamaicans at home and abroad gave money, food and building materials on trust. They are owed a line-by-line statement of what came in, where it went and who signed. A request for grace does not meet that debt. Neither does a whisper campaign about a clerk.



