‘I Genuinely Forgive You’: Gaston Browne Rejects a Citizen’s Apology, Lists His Grievances, and 4,100 Beach Signatures Are Still Waiting
Gaston Browne has dismissed Eli Fuller’s apology as insincere, listed long-standing grievances and then said he forgives him. The beach access petition of 4,100 signatures, which Browne says he supports, remains unanswered.

A citizen apologised to the Prime Minister of Antigua and Barbuda this week and said he was stepping away from public debate out of concern for his family and staff. The Prime Minister’s reply was to call the apology fake, accuse him of inventing the fear, air a list of old complaints and then announce his forgiveness. It is hard to think of a clearer picture of who holds the power in this exchange.
The dispute began when Eli Fuller presented Gaston Browne with a petition signed by more than 4,100 people, calling for practical public parking and convenient access to South Beach at Jolly Harbour and better beach access across the country. Browne has previously said he cursed Fuller after Fuller told him to burn the petition.
The apology
In an open letter Fuller wrote: ‘I would like to sincerely apologise for anything I may have said or done that you found offensive. That was never my intention.’ He said he had hoped for ‘a constructive conversation’, that he has ‘no political ambitions whatsoever’, and that the online hostility had reached a point where ‘I am genuinely concerned about the safety and well-being of my family and even my employees.’ He is taking a break from social media.
The reply
Browne opened by saying there was ‘nothing genuine about this apology’. He recalled that he had ‘graciously accepted the petition, shook his hand and commended him’, said the two were ‘fully aligned’ on the petition itself, and accused Fuller of choosing ‘to disrespect and violate my hospitality’.
He then dismissed the safety concerns, saying Fuller had ‘fabricated another drama’. ‘That’s not the Antiguan culture,’ Browne wrote. ‘We argue vehemently, we cuss and then we make up.’ He went on to allege that Fuller had called him corrupt, said he should be jailed over the creation of Peace Beach, questioned his ability to own a beach home as a Black man, and picketed his property. Those are the Prime Minister’s claims; Fuller’s letter did not address them. Browne concluded: ‘I genuinely forgive you for your infractions against me.’
A prime minister is not a private citizen
Browne is entitled to feel insulted, and to defend his name against things he says were said about him. What a head of government is not entitled to do is treat a public argument as a contest between equals. When the most powerful man in the country tells his very large following that a named citizen is insincere and a fabricator, that is not two neighbours cussing and making up. One of them commands the State. The other runs a business and has just said he is worried for his employees.
A leader secure in his office accepts an apology in one line, or ignores it. He does not reopen the file.
The petition is the point
Lost in all this is the only thing that matters to the public. By Browne’s own words he is ‘fully aligned’ with the petition. Good. Then the parking and the access at South Beach should be straightforward. What has the Government done about it since the signatures were delivered? What will it do, and by when?
Fuller wrote that perhaps ‘it is time for others to carry some of the weight’. Four thousand one hundred people already have. They did not sign to watch a feud. They signed to walk onto a beach that belongs to them. The Prime Minister says he agrees. He should prove it with a date.



