Skip to content
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

Barbados

Sack First, Ask Later? Barbados Bosses Are Told the Shortcut Will Cost More Than the Notice Pay They Tried to Dodge

A Barbados HR professional warns that employers who skip fair procedure or mislabel offences as gross misconduct risk heavy liability, citing the CCJ’s Massy Stores v Forde ruling.

Sack First, Ask Later? Barbados Bosses Are Told the Shortcut Will Cost More Than the Notice Pay They Tried to Dodge
Illustration: AI-generated image

Too many Barbadian employers still believe that catching a worker in the wrong is the same thing as being entitled to throw them out the door that afternoon. It is not, and a senior human resources professional has now spelled out how expensive that mistake can be.

Dylan Downes, human resources manager at PVH Group, warns that employers who dismiss without following proper disciplinary procedure face significant legal consequences even when the misconduct is proven. Dismissal disputes, he says, are a growing concern, and rushed proceedings are where the money is lost, above all in cases of summary dismissal.

The court has already settled this

The foundation is the Caribbean Court of Justice’s 2025 ruling in Massy Stores v Forde, which affirmed that procedural fairness is an implied term of every employment contract in Barbados. In practice that means a worker must be told the allegations, given a genuine chance to respond, and heard at a disciplinary meeting before any decision is made. Even when dismissal looks inevitable, the process still has to be fair.

Downes walks through what that looks like. Suspension during an investigation is paid, and it is a precaution, not a punishment. The employee should get a written invitation to a hearing that sets out the allegations, the possible consequences and the right to bring a representative. Seven days is generally accepted as reasonable time to prepare. Reasonable requests to postpone should be considered, though repeated or unjustified ones need not stall matters for ever.

Not every breach is gross misconduct

The sharper warning is about the favourite trick of the careless employer: labelling everything gross misconduct in order to avoid notice pay. Gross misconduct, Downes says, is conduct so serious it destroys the trust the relationship depends on, such as theft, physical assault, deliberate falsification of records or severe harassment. Persistent lateness or repeated insubordination belongs on the ladder of warnings that the Employment Rights Act 2012 expects.

‘A breach of company policy does not, by itself, justify summary dismissal,’ he says. Length of service, disciplinary record and whether the rule is applied consistently all count. A worker with 30 unblemished years may fairly be treated differently from one with a single year, though long service is no licence to ignore the rules.

Who this is really about

Strip away the careful HR language and the message is a rebuke to management. The paid suspension that employers resent is the price of getting the facts right. The week’s notice of a hearing is the price of being believed later. An employer who can dismiss lawfully with notice, and chooses instead to dress the case up as summary dismissal to save a few weeks’ wages, is gambling the company’s money on a tribunal not noticing.

Workers should read this advice as closely as their bosses. The law in Barbados does not protect bad behaviour, but it does guarantee a hearing, and anyone marched off the premises without one has a case worth taking advice on.

Downes urges employers facing complex cases to consult an employment lawyer or the Barbados Employers’ Confederation first. His closing line is the one to pin above every manager’s desk: ‘Shortcuts and disproportionate sanctions can leave employers liable for far more than the cost they sought to avoid.’ Cheap dismissals are the dearest kind.

0
0
Share this story

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Barbados

View all →

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.