Qualified, Local and Unemployed: BVI Boat Captains Are Sidelined While Charter Firms Import Crews by the Dozen
Opposition Leader Marlon Penn says charter companies are importing captains by the dozen while qualified BVI captains go without work, and wants Trade and Labour to stop approving the permits.

The British Virgin Islands calls itself a sailing capital. Its own licensed captains say they cannot get hired there.
Opposition Leader Marlon Penn told the House of Assembly he has received complaints about how local captains are treated in the marine industry, including onerous conditions imposed by charter companies. His charge is specific: firms are bringing in expatriate workers by the dozens while dozens of registered local captains with the same qualifications struggle to find work.
‘We cannot allow persons to continue to get away with abusing our own citizens when they have the ability and the qualifications. It’s been happening too long within this industry, and it has to stop,’ he said.
Somebody is signing the permits
Mr Penn aimed his fire at two government departments, and he chose the right targets. A charter company cannot import a captain on its own. It needs a trade licence and it needs a work permit. Both are issued by the State.
‘Trade Department has to put their foot down! Labour has to put their foot down!’ he said, asking how firms keep securing permits for foreign captains while qualified locals sit idle.
That is the question that matters. Every expatriate captain working in these waters represents a decision by a public official that no suitable local was available. If Mr Penn’s account is right, those decisions are being made dozens of times a year, in an industry where local candidates are on a register. Either the checks are not being done or the answers are being ignored.
Nobody in government can claim surprise
The complaint is not new and it is not confined to the opposition. At a marine industry forum in August, stakeholders described the barriers keeping BVIslanders from sharing in a lucrative sector: competition from expatriate workers, limited access to financing and inadequate training. Those who raised concerns included the Junior Minister for Culture, the Trade Minister and a former Trade Minister, who said local captains had complained of charter companies favouring expatriates.
There were also complaints of locals being made to train foreign counterparts who then took their jobs. It is hard to think of a clearer sign that the skill was there all along.
So ministers have heard this directly. Three months on, the Opposition Leader is still describing the same practice from the floor of the House. Companies, he noted, have been allowed to expand their services and operations while ‘our people are continuing to be sidelined’.
What putting a foot down looks like
The fix does not require new law. It requires the departments to use the powers they have. Publish the number of work permits issued for captains each year alongside the number of registered local captains. Require any company applying for a permit to show which local captains it interviewed and why each was turned down. Tie the renewal of trade licences to a record of local hiring.
The August forum also heard calls to reserve parts of the sector, particularly day charters, for locals. That deserves a decision, one way or the other, not another forum.
‘We have to get a grip of it fast,’ Mr Penn said. Quite. An industry built on these islands’ waters and reputation should not need to be forced to employ the people who grew up on them.



