Skip to content
Sunday, 22 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

Community

GPL Substation Terrorism Case: The DPP Wants Six Men Back in Jail Before a Single Fact Is Tested

A magistrate bailed six men charged with terrorism over the Good Hope GPL substation fire. The DPP wants them remanded, and the case already carries political weight.

GPL Substation Terrorism Case: The DPP Wants Six Men Back in Jail Before a Single Fact Is Tested
Illustration: AI-generated image

Guyana’s prosecutors have decided that a magistrate’s bail ruling in the GPL substation terrorism case is a threat to national security, and on Monday they will ask the Full Court to undo it. The six men charged are presumed innocent. The real contest now is not about them alone. It is about whether a terrorism label on a charge sheet is enough to switch off the ordinary rules of bail.

What the court decided, and what the DPP wants

On November 18, at their first appearance, Magistrate Teriq Mohamed of the Vigilance Magistrate’s Court granted cash bail to Alex Simpson, Timothy James, 18, Yannick McCalman, Osafo Browne, Shane Fordyce and Jonathan Cox. James was set at $99,000 and the others at $300,000 each, with conditions to report to police and notify any change of address. They are charged under Section 309A(1)(b)(ii) of the Criminal Law (Offences) Act over an alleged arson attack on November 9 to 10 at the Guyana Power and Light substation at Good Hope, East Coast Demerara. The charge alleges flammable substances were used with intent to threaten the country’s security or strike terror in the population.

Director of Public Prosecutions Shalimar Ali-Hack, SC, filed an appeal on Thursday under Section 17(1) of the Bail Act 2022. It is listed for Monday morning before Acting Chief Justice Navindra Singh and Justice Deborah Kumar-Chetty. The DPP says the magistrate gave too little weight to the gravity of the charge, its minimum sentence, the strength of the State’s case and the national security implications, and argues the alleged conduct had an ‘organised, financed, and continuing character’. She also contends that the Constitution gives no free-standing right to bail and that the magistrate misread Article 139 and Section 7 of the Bail Act. She wants the bail revoked, arrest warrants issued and the men remanded.

The magistrate had a point

The magistrate’s reasoning, as reported, was simple and orthodox: the seriousness of an offence alone does not justify detention before trial, each applicant’s circumstances must be weighed, and remand must never become punishment in advance. That is not softness. It is the presumption of innocence doing its job, and it matters most precisely when the State is angriest.

The appeal may succeed on the law; that is for the Full Court. But the public should notice what is being asked. If a terrorism charge is to mean automatic remand, Parliament should say so openly in the Bail Act, rather than prosecutors asking judges to read it in after the event.

Politics in the dock

The case is already political. Fordyce is the husband of We Invest in Nationhood MP Natasha Singh-Lewis and stood as a WIN candidate in the September 2025 elections. He, McCalman and Cox were re-arrested hours after being charged over a separate alleged arson at Strathspey Primary School and, police say, remain in custody, which makes Monday’s appeal partly academic for three of the six.

Meanwhile, the police have been unusually talkative. Investigators say an arrested suspect described two attackers and two planners and mentioned another planned attack in Georgetown. Crime Chief Wendell Blanhum has spoken of an alleged wider plot against another substation, the Umana Yana and schools. None of it has been tested in court.

That is the problem. When the case involves an opposition MP’s husband, the State has an extra duty to be seen to act on evidence, not on headlines. Briefing the public about plots before trial, then arguing that the strength of its own case justifies jail, risks looking like a prosecution conducted in the press. If the evidence is strong, it will survive a trial. The State should save it for one.

Monday’s ruling will set the tone for every terrorism charge that follows. The court should decide it on law and evidence, and the Government should stop deciding it on air.

0
0
Share this story

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Community

View all →

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.