Essequibo Talks: Guyana Says No to Venezuela, and Produces the Minutes to Prove It Always Did
Guyana has flatly ruled out bilateral Essequibo talks with Venezuela and says it holds minutes proving it rejected a US official's overture. Washington's wording still leaves a door ajar.

Essequibo talks with Venezuela are off the table, and Guyana wants the whole hemisphere, Washington included, to hear it said in the plainest words a foreign minister can find. Hugh Todd’s statement late on Friday was not diplomacy dressed in fog. It was a door slammed, bolted and photographed.
“Guyana has been very clear and very firm that we will not hold any bilateral discussions with Venezuela with regard to their controversy over the 1899 arbitral award,” Todd said. He told Guyanese to be patient and to stay focused on their future as a sovereign country. That is the right call. It is also a call Georgetown should never have needed to make this week.
What we know so far
The statement followed reporting that Jeremy Lewin, then the State Department’s policy chief and a prominent Trump appointee who left the department at the end of October, told Guyana’s Foreign Secretary Robert Persaud at a September meeting in Washington that he could help broker territorial talks with Venezuela’s acting president, Delcy Rodríguez. Two people also said Lewin floated Venezuela taking partial control of the Essequibo region, roughly two thirds of Guyana’s territory.
Todd says Persaud refused on the spot, insisting Guyana would pursue only the outcome of the case at the International Court of Justice. “Those discussions were minuted, and we, at the Foreign Ministry, are in possession of those notes,” the minister said. Hours earlier Rodríguez had repeated that Caracas wants the controversy settled by negotiation under its own reading of the 1966 Geneva Agreement. Guyana filed its case in 2018, hearings on the merits ran in May 2026, and Todd says judgment could arrive in the first quarter of 2027.
The United States Embassy has said its policy is unchanged and that the 1899 award should be respected “unless or until a new boundary is set by a competent legal body or with the consent of both parties”. Todd’s answer: for Guyana the competent body is the ICJ, under Article 4(2) of the Geneva Agreement, and the second path, consent, does not exist.
The loophole Washington left open
Here is the part the embassy’s friends would rather skip. A statement of support that names neither the court nor the award’s finality, and that sketches a second route through “consent”, is not a guarantee. It is an option kept warm. The international relations scholar Mark Kirton has said those phrases look like indicators of American interest in influencing a negotiation. He is right to be worried, and Georgetown is right to answer with documents rather than reassurance.
The opposition agrees on substance. APNU leader Aubrey Norton says no territory must be ceded and there must be no arrangement giving Venezuela involvement in or control over any part of Essequibo. Amanza Walton of the Forward Guyana Movement wants the government to explain what US Defence Secretary Peter Hegseth meant by his references to Venezuelan territory after signing a military cooperation agreement with Caracas. Those are fair questions, and the government should answer them in public, not in briefings.
Who should answer for this
Guyana has done its part: one position, stated orally, written down and now waved in public. The burden now sits in Washington. If the United States truly backs the court, it should say “the ICJ” and drop the consent clause. Until it does, every assurance is worth exactly the paper it was not printed on. Guyana should keep its nerve, keep its minutes and let the judges finish their work.



