Skip to content
Friday, 20 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

Barbados

Private Clinics Took the Tax Breaks. Barbados Now Wants to Know How Many Patients That Buys

Health Minister Lisa Cummins wants private medical facilities to convert their tax concessions into care for the public under a national healthcare network. The idea is sound; the contract is everything.

Private Clinics Took the Tax Breaks. Barbados Now Wants to Know How Many Patients That Buys
Illustration: AI-generated image

For years Barbados has handed tax and duty concessions to private medical facilities without asking what the public gets back. Health Minister Lisa Cummins has finally asked the question out loud.

Speaking at the opening of Urgent Care’s W Hospital in St Thomas, Senator Cummins outlined a model her ministry is reviewing: a ‘national medical campus’ that links providers across the island so that Barbadians can get state-supported treatment near where they live, instead of everyone converging on the Queen Elizabeth Hospital.

The sharpest part of her pitch was about money. ‘If I’m able to benefit from, let’s say $100 000 in concessions or $50 000 in concessions, what is the equivalent of that? How many persons can I treat for that amount because you’ve been taking it off the government’s revenue, right?’ she said.

The right question, asked late

That is exactly the right way to think about it. A concession is public money by another name. If a private hospital imports equipment duty-free, the Treasury has paid part of the price, and it is reasonable for the public to receive care in return. The surprise is that this is being worked out now, at a ribbon-cutting, rather than being a condition from the day the first concession was granted.

The geography argument is also sound. ‘Distance matters. Logistics matter,’ the minister said. Someone in St Philip may be closer to a polyclinic or emergency facility in the parish than to Martindale’s Road; someone in St Thomas can reach the new hospital at Welches faster. ‘There is no space for us versus them,’ she said. ‘We are too small for that.’

Where it could go wrong

The ministry has held talks with private providers, including Urgent Care Barbados, and has received a formal proposal on how a partnership could work. A committee is now working through it with the QEH. And there lies the risk. The plan being assessed was drafted, at least in part, by a business that stands to gain from it, and was praised at that business’s own opening.

None of that makes it a bad plan. It does mean the details decide everything. What is in the ‘defined package of services’? Who sets the price the State pays when a patient walks into a private facility? Who audits whether the value of care delivered matches the value of concessions received? And what stops public money flowing outwards while the QEH, which will still take the most serious and expensive cases, is left with less?

The minister said the aim is access ‘without prohibitive out-of-pocket costs’. That phrase needs a number attached before anyone signs.

Publish the terms

Barbadians have waited long enough in the QEH’s corridors to welcome anything that shortens the queue. But a public-private network is only as good as its contract. The Government should publish the proposal it has received, name the members of the committee, and state the formula for converting concessions into care.

If the sums favour patients, the minister will have done something her predecessors did not. If they are kept private, the public will be entitled to assume they favour someone else.

0
0
Share this story

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Barbados

View all →

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.