Skip to content
Saturday, 21 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

Grenada

Minister of Sport and Football Vice-President: Carl Andall Cannot Referee a Game He Is Playing In

Grenada’s new Sports Minister Carl Andall is still 1st Vice-President of the Grenada Football Association. No rule expressly forbids it, but FIFA and GFA statutes demand independence from politics, and the GFA is silent.

Minister of Sport and Football Vice-President: Carl Andall Cannot Referee a Game He Is Playing In
Photo: Stabbur's Master / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)

Grenada now has a Minister responsible for Sports who is also the second most senior elected official in the country’s football association. Nobody has explained how he intends to sit on both sides of the same table, and the Grenada Football Association is not answering questions.

Carl Andall’s recent appointment to the sports portfolio has drawn fresh attention because he continues to serve as 1st Vice-President of the GFA. The arrangement has reportedly caused concern among some football clubs. As of the latest reporting, the association had neither responded to a request for comment nor made any public statement.

What the rules say

To be fair to Andall, he has not been shown to have broken any rule. The GFA’s statutes do not expressly bar a government minister from serving on its Council, and they do not automatically disqualify someone for running for office, entering Parliament or joining Cabinet. Holding two positions is not the same as abusing one to benefit the other.

But the principles point one way. FIFA’s 2024 Statutes, at Article 14(1)(c), oblige member associations to manage their affairs independently and without influence from third parties. Article 15(c) requires statutes to guard against political interference, and Article 19 repeats the demand for independence. The GFA’s own Article 5 requires neutrality in politics and says the association must avoid any form of undue political interference.

A minister is not a neutral party in politics. He is politics.

Where the conflict bites

The danger is not some dramatic act of meddling. It is the ordinary business between a ministry and a federation: government funding for football, the allocation of grounds and facilities, national sports policy, appointments, and every negotiation in which the Ministry and the GFA sit opposite each other.

In each of those, who is Andall representing? When the GFA asks the Ministry for money, is its 1st Vice-President asking or answering? When the Ministry sets priorities among sports, does football’s man in Cabinet recuse himself, and if he does, what is the point of him being Minister for Sports? Every other sporting body in Grenada is entitled to wonder whether it is competing for resources on a level field.

There is also the association’s exposure. Federations judged to be under government influence can come under scrutiny within FIFA’s governance framework. That has not happened here, and the mere fact of his ministerial office is not in itself a breach. But a small association should not be testing how much ambiguity world football will tolerate.

The simple fix

This does not need a commission of inquiry. It needs one resignation letter or one very clear set of public rules. Andall could step down from the GFA post, which is the clean answer. Failing that, the association and the Ministry should publish, in writing, exactly which decisions he will stay out of on each side and who will take them instead.

What is not acceptable is the present position: a minister wearing both hats and a football association saying nothing at all. Silence from the GFA is not neutrality. It looks like an organisation that has not worked out whether it is allowed to disagree with its own vice-president now that he sits in Cabinet. That, precisely, is the problem the statutes were written to prevent.

0
0
Share this story

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More in Grenada

View all →

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.