Skip to content
Thursday, 19 November 2026 · London · Kingston · Port of Spain
My account
CaribDirect

News and stories from the Caribbean and its diaspora

Community

Collymore Case Collapses Without a Word of Explanation, and the Public Is Told to Move On

Jamaica's DPP told the court the Crown could not proceed against Omar Collymore and three others over a 2017 shooting. Not-guilty verdicts were entered and no public reasons were given.

Collymore Case Collapses Without a Word of Explanation, and the Public Is Told to Move On
Illustration: AI-generated image

A case that took nearly nine years to reach a courtroom ended in a few minutes on Tuesday, when Jamaica’s Director of Public Prosecutions told a judge the Crown was not in a position to proceed. Four men walked away from charges of conspiracy to murder, shooting with intent and illegal possession of a firearm with formal not-guilty verdicts. The public, which has paid for every day of that prosecution, was not told why.

What happened in court

The accused were Omar Collymore, Carey Jonas, Dwayne Pink and Michael Adams. The charges arose from an allegation that a woman’s vehicle was shot at several times on Sandy Park Road in St Andrew on 23 December 2017. The Crown’s case was that she had been in a three-year relationship with Collymore that ended about two months earlier.

DPP Claudette Thompson told Justice Leighton Pusey that the prosecution could not go ahead. She said she had informed the investigating officer and the complainant, and had explained the reasons to the woman. The judge then entered not-guilty verdicts for all four. In law, that is the end of it: they are not guilty of these charges.

A fifth man, Shaquilla Edwards, had pleaded guilty to conspiracy to murder in July and was sentenced to seven years and six months, but was released after credit for time already spent in custody.

Why it matters anyway

Some will shrug. Collymore, Pink and Adams are already serving life sentences after being convicted in May 2024 of the 2018 murders of businesswoman Simone Campbell-Collymore and her driver, Winston Walters. Collymore must serve 46 years and six months before he can be considered for parole. Nobody is going home.

That is precisely the lazy thinking a justice system cannot afford. One of the four, Carey Jonas, is not among those convicted of the murders in the reporting, and he spent years with these charges over his head. A complainant waited almost nine years to see a trial that never came. And a prosecution that secured a guilty plea from one defendant in July found itself unable to offer evidence against the other four by November.

The reasons belong to the public too

The DPP did the decent thing by explaining herself to the woman at the centre of the case. But the decision was made in the name of the Crown, which is to say in the name of all of us, and the reasons were not given in open court according to the reports. Was a witness unavailable? Did evidence degrade over nine years? Did something emerge in July that changed the picture? Each answer points to a different failure, and without one nobody can fix anything.

There is no suggestion of impropriety, and prosecutors must be free to drop cases they cannot prove. That discretion is a safeguard. It is also a power, and powers exercised in silence erode trust. Jamaica’s courts are choked with matters that take the better part of a decade to be heard, and every year of delay makes outcomes like this more likely.

The Office of the DPP should publish a short statement of reasons whenever a serious case is abandoned at the door of the court, with whatever is needed held back to protect witnesses. A nine-year wait deserves more than one sentence from the bar table.

0
0

More in Community

View all →

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The Caribbean, delivered.

Business, community and culture from the islands and the diaspora, in your inbox.