Belize Is Sending a Minister to Study Bukele’s Prisons. Dickie Bradley Is Right: That Is Not a Crime Plan
Attorney Dickie Bradley says Belize’s violence is driven by a handful of people and a failure of leadership, and that copying El Salvador’s mass-detention model is no substitute for a plan.

When a government runs out of ideas on crime, it buys a plane ticket. Belize’s is to El Salvador, where Home Affairs Minister Michel Chebat is expected to travel to study President Nayib Bukele’s hardline strategy against gangs.
Veteran attorney Richard ‘Dickie’ Bradley has seen enough to object before the minister has packed. His warning is blunt: do not model Belize’s response on El Salvador. And his diagnosis is one the Government will not enjoy. ‘This is a crisis of leadership and a failure to tackle social and economic problems,’ he said.
A handful of people, not an army
Bradley’s central point is about scale. Belize, he argues, is not dealing with a thousand or two thousand young men shooting up the place. It is dealing with ‘a handful of people’. If that is right, and the people who work in Belize’s courts are well placed to judge, then the Salvadoran model is the wrong tool by design. Bukele’s approach is built on mass detention. You do not need to sweep up a generation to deal with a few dozen known shooters. You need detectives, witnesses who feel safe, prosecutors who can get a case to trial and a court system that finishes what it starts.
He pointed to the recent shooting on the Coastal Road that left four men dead and came before the declaration of a State of Emergency. The response, he said, exposed ‘the lack of any kind of solution, any attempt at solution’. That is a hard charge, and the sequence gives it weight: killings, then emergency powers, then a study tour.
The language, and the substance beneath it
Bradley did not hold back on El Salvador itself. He called its method a ‘Nazi Gestapo approach’ in which people are picked up and treated ‘like animals’, and alleged that detainees there are held in inhumane conditions that do not make the news. The comparison is his, and it is heated. The concern underneath is one that human rights bodies have raised about El Salvador for years, and it is the part Belizeans should think about. Powers created for gang members do not stay confined to gang members. They are used on whoever the police find convenient.
He also put his finger on what the trip says about the Government’s thinking. Instead of writing its own plan, he said, it has decided to ‘check on Bukele and see if we could bring something back here’. That is policy as souvenir shopping.
What the Government says it is doing
Ministers say they are looking at a range of measures, including legislative reform and a second chance programme for young men at risk. Good. Those are the beginnings of a home-grown answer, and they deserve money and attention. A second chance scheme that is properly funded would do more for Belize City than any number of photographs taken outside a Salvadoran mega-prison.
So here is the test for Chebat when he returns. Tell the country what he saw that would work in a nation of Belize’s size, with Belize’s constitution and Belize’s courts, and what it would cost. If the answer is more emergencies and more cells, Bradley will have been proved right, and the handful of people doing the shooting will still be out there.
